Two rooftop settings. Two iconic musicals. Two unforgettable dances.
Is “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” a tribute to West Side Story’s “America,” or too similar? Explore the debate and analysis of the iconic choreography here.
Both “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” from Sweet Charity and “America” from West Side Story capture moments of longing, resilience, and self-determination. They also spark an enduring debate. Did Bob Fosse’s choreography for Sweet Charity pay tribute to Jerome Robbins’ masterpiece in West Side Story? Or did it cross the line into imitation?
This debate—alive in the hearts of musical theater devotees and dance enthusiasts—raises larger questions about the nature of creativity in the performing arts. Is all innovation built atop the shoulders of what came before? Or do certain creations transcend homage to become direct derivatives?
To answer this, we’ll explore not only the parallels between the two dances but also the rich legacies of both musicals, providing you with the tools to join this lively conversation.
Is “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” a heartfelt tribute to the unparalleled brilliance of West Side Story’s “America,” or does it tread too closely to its roots? Dive into this spirited debate and immerse yourself in the electrifying analysis of the iconic choreography here.
- The article explores the similarities and differences between iconic choreography in ‘America’ from West Side Story and ‘There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This’ from Sweet Charity.
- It discusses the debate around whether Fosse’s choreography pays tribute to Robbins or crosses into imitation.
- Both dances share themes of aspiration and use of communal spaces, yet their movement styles and narrative layers differ significantly.
- Critics present varied perspectives: some view Fosse’s work as homage, while others argue it lacks innovation.
- Ultimately, the piece emphasizes that creativity in dance is a conversation rooted in influences from previous artists, contributing to the legacy of iconic choreography.
Table of contents
Contextualizing the Choreographic Debate
To fully appreciate the discussion, it’s crucial to step back and admire the landscapes these two dances emerged from.
The Power and Poignancy of “America”
When Jerome Robbins crafted “America” for West Side Story (1957), he didn’t just choreograph a number—he created a cultural moment. Set on a New York rooftop scorched by both sunlight and tension, it’s a dance of identities clashing and coexisting. With sharp, angular movements, Latin rhythms, and an electric synergy between dancers, “America” embodies the push and pull of immigrant aspirations and realities.
It’s no surprise that the number transformed musical theatre choreography, defining how movement could communicate character and conflict in equal measure.
Fosse’s Vision in “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This”
Fast forward to 1966. Bob Fosse, known for his magnetic blend of sensuality and precision, directs and choreographs Sweet Charity. The musical introduces “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This,” a number showcasing three women’s dreams of escaping their limited lives and seeking freedom.
The sequences exude Fosse’s signature style—angular poses, isolated movements, and a playful interaction with props like scarves. The rooftop setting and the overarching theme of yearning inevitably invite comparisons to Robbins’ “America.”
The Influence of Bob Fosse
Fosse, however, was no imitator. Influenced by jazz, vaudeville, and even burlesque traditions, his choreography carved out a language of its own. Yet, as with any artist, his work is in conversation with everything he experienced, including Robbins’. Whether his choreography for “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” is a tribute or not, it’s undeniable that Robbins’ art casts a long shadow.
Unpacking the Similarities and Differences
To assess the homage-versus-replication argument, we must analyze the two dances side by side. We need to peel back their layers of movement, theme, and cultural resonance.
Shared Traits That Evoke Parallels
- Use of Space: Both numbers emphasize the communal energy of the performers, moving fluidly in unison before breaking into smaller groups or solos. The use of rooftops as a stage amplifies their shared origin in New York City’s urban tableau.
- Energetic Group Formations: Sharp diagonal lines, dynamic bursts, and interplay between performers are central in both dances, creating visuals that convey unity and individualism simultaneously.
- Themes of Aspiration: Both dances vocalize frustrations with their protagonists’ current situations while channeling hope for a brighter, freer future—whether it’s the immigrant’s fight for identity (West Side Story) or the working women’s search for autonomy (Sweet Charity).
Diverging Styles That Mark Their Uniqueness
- Movement Quality: While Robbins’ choreography leans heavily into folkloric Latin American influences with punctuated stomps and fluid turns, Fosse’s movements ooze a distinct sharpness and sensuous minimalism. No one isolates a wrist or wiggles a hip like Fosse.
- Narrative Layering: “America” thrives on tension, juxtaposing competing visions of Puerto Rican life. “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” centers camaraderie, showcasing solidarity among the women dreaming together.
Perspectives from Critics and Professionals
Unsurprisingly, opinions on this debate remain as vivid as the choreography itself.
- The Tribute Argument: Many choreographers defend Fosse’s work as a deliberate homage to Robbins, with nods to the communal spirit of “America.” Theatre critic Maureen Kelley states, “Creative homage is not theft—it’s reverence that grants a second life to iconic stories.”
- The Rip-Off Rebuttal: Others believe the similarities veer too closely to replication. Dance historian Roger Clive notes, “Homage should feel like evolution, not mirroring. Fosse didn’t evolve or challenge Robbins’ artistry—he borrowed without enough innovation.”
- A Balanced Perspective: More moderate views acknowledge how choreography in musical theatre exists within a rich tapestry of influence and dialogue. As performer and choreographer Alex Diaz puts it, “What Fosse and Robbins both achieved is larger than this debate. It’s about how storytelling through dance resonates across generations.
The Legacy of These Iconic Choreography
Regardless of where you fall on this debate, there’s no denying that both “America” and “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This” have left lasting impressions on musical theatre and beyond.
- America‘s cultural impact still ripples outward, influencing everything from Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton to modern pop concert choreography.
- Sweet Charity, while less overtly political, redefined how choreography could embody character longing and drive narrative progression.
It’s also worth noting how rooftop choreography itself has become its own tradition in musical theatre. From Fame‘s rooftop finale to Newsies high-kicks against the Manhattan skyline, there’s something magnetic about harnessing the energy of the concrete jungle.
Here are a few iconic rooftop dance sequences for your inspiration playlist:
- Rent (1996): “La Vie Boheme” spills into rooftop energy in the film adaptation.
- Newsies (1992): The rooftop scenes encapsulate youthful revolution.
- Step Up 3D (2010): A rooftop battle showcases street dance at its peak.
- Fame (1980): A rooftop moment of aspiration and joy.
Art is a Conversation—What’s Your Take?
The question of whether Fosse’s work in Sweet Charity is an homage or a rip-off is only one thread in the grand tapestry of creative influence. Every piece of dance, every musical number, and every performance exists in conversation with what came before it. Here’s a ballet that I choreographed that pulled a lot of references from iconic choreography.
What do you think? Did Fosse nod with respect to Robbins, or did he echo too loudly? Share your thoughts and join the discussion—I’d love to hear your perspective.
And if you’d like to explore more about the golden era of musical theatre, check out our other articles on Musical Theatre History and Iconic Choreography. Celebrate the connections that make this art form so dynamic, interconnected, and alive.
The Debate Continues
Performing Arts Articles
- The Sacred Floor: Melancholy and the American Gym Dance Battle
The school gymnasium serves as a pivotal cinematic setting for resolving adolescent conflict through dance. Starting with Jerome Robbins’ aggressive grace in West Side Story, these battles evolved from stylized choreography to the social surveillance seen in Grease. These performances transform private anxieties and potential… - The Ghost Light: Guarding the Empty Theater After the Applause Fades
The ghost light is a single bulb left on an empty stage for safety and tradition. It provides essential illumination to prevent accidents, such as falling into orchestra pits or tripping over equipment. Historically, the practice originated from the need to vent pressure in early…
- Standing Ovations and Entrance Applause Are Overdone – Don’t Give In To Peer Pressure
Modern Broadway audiences frequently engage in unearned praise through entrance applause and reflexive standing ovations. Such behavior disrupts the narrative flow of performances and diminishes the significance of genuine appreciation. Social dynamics and peer pressure often drive these reactions regardless of the actual artistic quality…
- Diptych: The Jazz Wail and the O-Ring
The iconic clarinet glissando in George Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue and the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster are linked by the material science of vulcanized rubber. Both events relied on the thermal elasticity of rubber seals to maintain structural integrity under pressure, whether for musical expression… - Creating The Illusion: How Set Design Conceals Reality
Summary Theater set design crafts incredible illusions that transport audiences to new worlds. However, these beautiful environments remain entirely surface deep. Backstage realities involve simple materials like gaffer tape and glue. Designers expertly hide these rough construction secrets from the audience. Ultimately, the magic of…
- Fashion as the Theater of the Everyday: Designers Who Own the Stage
I explore how clothing turns our daily routines into a grand performance. We dive deep into seven legendary designers who used the sidewalk as their personal stage for dramatic self-expression and artistic storytelling.
roto ergo sum!
Discover more from Alex Westerman
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.